Oregairu Analysis – The TRUTH(s) behind Hayato’s Sacrifice for Hachiman (Part 2)

In cerebration about news Oregairu LN v12 is in progress, let me launch New Year gift 2017 for you & all Oregairu fans. Oregairu analysis focused on Hayama Hayato (葉山 隼人) during the doughnut cafe – Hayato’s heroic performance.

In part1, Hayato is called by Yukinoshita Haruno (雪ノ下 陽乃) to come to the doughnut cafe and falls to her trap (he must go have fun with Orimoto and Nakasomething). And he realizes her true objective to send him to that battlefield. If he follows her operation, the worst ending will descend to him for sure (you can read the worst ending in Operation Fire Doughnut part 3). So he needs to “do something”. That’s why you can see him goes to talk with Hikigaya Hachiman (比企谷 八幡).

Hayama Hayato MUST use Hikigaya Hachiman in the date. (Oregairu Zoku ep4)
I need you, Hkitani-kun.

I can say that from what “Hayato confronts those two girls for Hachiman’s sake”, and when I look back, “he invites Hachiman to the date” <— is the first sign that he is planning to counter Haruno’s operation. Why do I think like this? Why does Hayato need Hachiman to this event too? I will explain about this in the last part of this Hayato analysis about the truths behinds his heroic acting. I assume that he would plan to force Hachiman to his plan, in the same day he falls Haruno’s trap.

When Hayato decides to “use” Hachiman to counter Haruno’s operation, I think his intelligence and his original self starts to think how to use him to other problems too. I will not tell you for now because all questions why each characters (Hachiman, Haruno, Yukino and Yuigahama) gather to that cafe and Hayato starts to unleash his finishing move “Holy Breath” (in LN v8 c5, anime Zoku ep4), will be revealed in the last part of this Hayato analysis. Please be patient and I want you to take your time and think there is something fishy in his action. I can say for now that Hayato is like what Haruno says after he confronts those girls.

I can say for now that Hayato will use anything/anyone and manipulates them to do as he wants. His intelligence is S but his bravery is F. I will explain you in the last part why I think like this.

What happened in LN v8 c3, anime Zoku ep3, I assumeed in Haruno’s operation part 3 that Hayato would do something wrong in the past when the bullying incident happened in the elementary school he and Yukino studied. And the hatred Haruno has to him is feeling to what he did back then. I mentioned in part 3 that Haruno hates him from the bottom in her heart because after he did something wrong and the bullying, her sister, Yukinoshita Yukino (雪ノ下 雪乃) went to study abroad. I can say Hayato wants to do something to her hatred too. But like usual, I will explain in the last part.

So in this part, I will explain how Hayato plans and prepares before the showdown, hanging out with Orimoto Kaori (折本 かおり) and Nakasomething will start. But I will not reveal why he plans this.

ps.

  • Please read Attention page first, to let you understand that my all analysis are not 100% right.
  • Spoilers up ahead.
  • I recommend you to read/watch Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatteiru. (やはり俺の青春ラブコメはまちがっている。) LN/animeYahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatteiru. Zoku (やはり俺の青春ラブコメはまちがっている。続)/manga Yahari Ore no Seishun Rabu Kome wa Machigatteiru. -Monologue- (やはり俺の青春ラブコメはまちがっている。-妄言録-) before proceed.
    I strongly recommend LN because some info in this analysis, can’t find in anime or manga. LN has the most detail/story more than other media.
  • This analysis will explain the timeline after what happened in the doughnut cafe and before the date will start. So I recommend you to read Haruno’s operation Fire Doughnut part 4 since this will explain how Hayato prepares his countermeasure indirectly too. And if you don’t read the first part of the truths behind Hayato‘s sacrifaction, please read this first before read this part 2.

Hayato’s countermasure
Chiba Perfecture, Tokyo,
LN v8, Anime Zoku ep 3-4, Manga -Monologue- v7

When does Hayato start the countermeasure?

I assume that Hayato would start to think about how he will survive from Haruno’s operation, in the same day when he comes to the doughnut shop. Because when I look his whole plan, I think he needs enough time to ensure his plan will be perfect/successful and can solve all problems in one blow. I think he is genius to think a complex countermeasure like that, but he needs time to think about this carefully.

Why do I think Hayato plans something?

There are too many fishy hints/clues that Hayato’s heroic action in ep4 is weird in my opinion.

  1. Haruno’s opinion – Do you still remember when Haruno tells him that people who can just handle everything flawlessly blah blah blah, don’t you? I notice that Haruno that time would realize about his countermeasure already (or should I say, she is the only who finally know his true intention(s).). So what she tells him is just sarcastic words but within these sarcastic words of her makes me think she sees him as the genius who has high intelligence that can solve all problems and trick even someone like her too.
  2. The presence of Yukino and Yui – At first, I don’t get why they appear to the cafe. I know Hayato calls them, but he needs to call them while he is hanging out with other girls? This is not make sense to me at first place, but when I realized his objective…
    And of course I will explain about this in the last part of Hayato analysis.
  3. Hayato’s expression – Do you still remember after Hayato confronted those girls and everyone leave except him and Hachiman or not? He looks gloomy/disappointed. You can say he is not please to sacrifice himself to protect Hachiman. This is understandable. But I don’t think his expression will match with how he should feel after did that either. It would be understandable if he will feel tired or scared because he never do something like that before. But his expression that time is not consistent with his heroic action. That’s why I suspect this moment too.

The starting point of Hayato’s multidimensional plan

I am sure that Hachiman is the starting point. I mentioned before in part 1 that Hayato will use him to counter Haruno’s operation. After he knows Haruno’s true objective, he needs to do something or the calamity will descend to him sooner or later. So he needs a boy who can join in the group so everyone who might see them will not misunderstand and cause the rumor.

Why does Hayato not invite his friends?

I think if Hayato will invite someone in his clique, he can do. But when I think in depth, I think inviting his friends is bad choice in its own way too.

  • In case he invites just one friend – This can’t do. It will be like double date, so this choice can’t solve Hayato’s problem. So this choice will be cut!
  • In case he invites 2-3 people (Tobe Kakeru (戸部 翔), Ooka (大岡) and Yamato (大和)) – This can do. But it can’t solve the whole problem either. Because if he counts three people more in this date group, it would be a big group and it still stands out. In people’ point of view, it will be him and his friends would invite two girls to have fun together. Although he can avoid the threesome (he+Orimoto+Nakasomething), he still can’t avoid to be noticed by Zobu students anyway. And if the gossip about Hayato’s clique hang out with two girls from other school, this gossip will reach someone’s ear in his classroom. And guess who will be shock from this gossip, …Miura Yumiko (三浦 優美子). I am sure Hayato will not let his AT-field will be destroyed for sure. So this choice will be cut!

Hayama Hayato (葉山 隼人) Yuigahama Yui (由比ヶ浜 結衣) Miura Yumiko (三浦 優美子) Ebina Hina (海老名 姫菜) Tobe Kakeru (戸部 翔) Ooka (大岡) Yamato (大和) in the classroom. (Oregairu Zoku ep1)A certain blond hair girl in the center will…

So any choices is bad. I will conclude Hayato can’t invite them or any of them to stop Haruno’s operation for sure. If three boy band doesn’t work, he would find some boy to join instead.

Why is Hachiman the only choice for Hayato?

We and Hayato know Hachiman is not involve with the group dates in the first place. So inviting him is weird and although he invites him, he would refuse anyway. But

  • I will tell you that Hayato is having “big other problems” too before he comes to the doughnut cafe. I will explain about big problems in the last part of this analysis.
  • Hayato possesses high intelligence. He can find how to solve those big problems in one go. (and I will explain why I think like that in the last part.) I can tell you for now that for Hayato’s point of view, he super duper supreme gigantic hates Hachiman million percent more than anyone anything in the universe (and I am not kidding). I can’t deny this anymore because from what happened in anime Zoku ep4, it appears that if he forced Hachiman to join this group dates, he can use/manipulate/burn him to save him from Haruno’s calamity, to solve his own big problems and if he gains all achievements he is wishing, he will toss Hachiman like some kind of trash in the end because …I can’t tell you for now about this either so I will just short it that because he hates him so much. He will manipulate Hachiman for his own hatred/impulse/self-satisfaction. After I review Hayato’s multidimensional plan, I realize how he feels toward Hachiman. Please don’t let his nice face trick you. Although he seems not feel angry/upset Hachiman so much like I wrote, but he can’t hide his feeling after I realize his true intention(s) for his plan.

So Hachiman is the only choice Hayato must force him to this group dates at any costs. If he can bring this loner (who lives in the lowest social chain) to this group, people who saw them will not misunderstand and the rumor will be prevented.

Orimoto Kaori & Nakamachi Chika show clothes they choose to Hayama Hayato. (Oregairu Zoku ep4)
Like this, people who saw them, can misunderstand and cause rumor.

 

It will be like this instead, got it?

How Hayato drags Hachiman.

Hayato tells Hachiman about the time of the group dates with Orimoto and Nakasomething. Hachiman tells him he doesn’t know about this. Hayato is surprised he doesn’t know. Hayato seems not get it and tilts his head. and says he thinks those girls means all of them when they said they all wanted to go out. Later, he concludes Hachiman is not invited so he smiles and invites him. He bows and asks Hachiman to come along and think this as helping him out. But Hachiman refuses this. He says…

“I won’t be of any help to you nor are you the kind of guy who needs it.”

And he tells him he will not leave house because it’s weekend.

#1 – Hayato is the mimicker.

In this scene when Hayato comes to tell Hachiman about the group dates, I think he starts by copying Haruno’s style. When I read this scene in LN v8 c5, I notice the way he is acting/pretending (such as surprised, tilts his head, etc.) are the same style Haruno likes to use. So it means he would see her acted like that too often and thinks her style would work for this situation when he must pretend he is stupid boy. And we see it works, doesn’t it? Because even Hachiman tells him he is stupid or not.

#2 – This confirms Hayato will force Hachiman.

Hayato this time decided he will use Hachiman but will pretend to ask him politely. However, when he tells Hachiman “to come along and think this as helping him out”, I notice how Hayato inserts his intention about he just want to use him, not ask him for help. When he tells Hachiman like this, it seems that he wants Hachiman misunderstand that it is like he tells him. But his true intention is different completely.

#3 – Hachiman’s words is interesting more than you think.

“I won’t be of any help to you nor are you the kind of guy who needs it.”

After Hachiman refuses Hayato to join in the group dates since he thinks he should invite some friend instead, he drops some interesting words before he leaves. I think this would be his own opinion only. But when look from another point of view, I start to think this would be the message from Watari-sensei himself to point out Hayato’s true intention about try to drag Hachiman. And if my assumption is not wrong, this dialogue is telling me that…

Hachiman won’t be of any help to Hayato nor Hayato is the kind of guy who needs it.

If my assumption about Hayato is trying to use Hachiman is true, I don’t see he wants any help from Hachiman either. Because he will use him, not ask him for help. So he actually doesn’t need help from Hachiman, because in Hayato’s point of view, Hachiman is some kind like victim/bait/obstacle he will use/manipulate/burn in his own plan. So that’s why I don’t see any reasons that makes Hayato needs Hachiman’s help.

#4 – The difference between “ask for help” and “pretending”.

Moreover, if Hayato wants to need “help” from Hachiman, he would beg him just like when he asked him to stop Tobe from confession in Zoku ep2. I suspect he doesn’t want to be in-debt to Hachiman anymore. Just that time is enough. That’s why this time he doesn’t tell any reason why he must invite Hachiman. Although in anime Zoku ep2&4, we see Hayato bows to Hachiman, but his feelings from those two situation are different completely.

That time (in ep2), Hayato can’t stand it because he has no choice but asks help from the one who he hates the most. He needs to swallow his pride and bows. His expression and words back then, give me this assumption.

This time (in ep4), It seems Hayato has some plan in his mind.
When I read to this point Hayato bows to Hachiman, I realize he is pretending to ask him. Why do I think like this? Because why is it difficult to Hayato to not understand those girls just want to hang out with him only, Hachiman is not relate to their fun tour at the first place. And this is Hayato who is very smart to the same level with Haruno? This doesn’t make sense to me at all. So I assume his actions…

  1. Hayato pretends to tell Hachiman to go out with him and those girls in Saturday.
  2. Hayato acts like he doesn’t understand why Hachiman doesn’t know the schedule, and tilts his head.
  3. Hayato pretends to realize Hachiman is not invited.

#5 – The trigger to the next phase.

Another my assumption is, if Hayato pretends to act so he can start to invite Hachiman to this group dates, is true. It means he is planning something and needs Hachiman as the starting point for his scheme.

The last interesting clue is Hayato would know Hachiman will refuse his invitation anyway. Why do I think he pretend to ask for help? Because it’s high possibility that Hachiman will refuse this invitation because he wouldn’t gain anything from this event. I don’t see why Hayato will not see this will come, so I assume he would know Hachiman must refuse definitely. So that’s why I think he pretends to ask help. After he hears Hachiman refuse his invitation, his rejection becomes the trigger for “the next phase”. That’s why when Hachiman is leaving from the classroom after he refuses Hayato’s invitation, Hayato murmurs,

“I see.”

I assume that it’s time he will ask another “trump card”.

Hikigaya Hachiman's rejection is the trigger for Hayama Hayato to enter the next phase. (Oregairu Zoku Ep 4)
…I see this would happen, so I will “ask” that person to force you.

When I said earlier about “maximum benefits”, I can say Hayato will not just gain one benefit only. If his plan is successful and no one notice his countermeasure, he will gain many benefits. So that’s why Hachiman’s role to Hayato’s plan is not just join the group dates to prevent the rumor only.

His trump card

I think you would know already who is trump card when I mentioned about Hayato will use it after Hachiman refuses his invitation. Do you still remember when Hachiman still sits in the sofa in his house in the midnight, don’t you? Someone calls to him via his sister’s phone, Hikigaya Komachi (比企谷 小町).

Hikigaya Hachiman can't believe Yukinoshita Haruno will call. (Oregairu Zoku ep 4)
You should upload Haruno’s picture, Komachi.

Yes, this trump card is Haruno. You can read Haruno’s operation Fire Doughnut part 4 since the timeline is the same from this analysis. This post will help you can see the situation clearer.

Many people wonder why Haruno knows Hayato invited and even bowed Hachiman to the group dates. This is understandable, because Hayato is the one who lets her know. Why do I think like this?

Because when you think about the timeline when Haruno calls to Hachiman, it is still the same day Hayato invites him. So when you look from timeline, it is high possibility that he would contact her and discuss about the group dates. And I assume that he knows Haruno-san very well since they played together in the past. So he would know he can use her if he tells her about he tries to invite and even bow to Hachiman but he refused. If he reports her like this, she would fall into his trap and is super duper curious why he needs Hachiman for this event so much.

So she would try to ask Hayato why he did that, he would not say anything but right now he succeeds to make Haruno is interested and suspects that he must need Hachiman in order to do something for sure. So it will not be surprising if she volunteers to force Hachiman to this group dates. That’s why it ends up she and him plan about this date event together (such as the quiet place).

I assume that Hayato would know she will spy on this event for sure, because he is the one who makes her interested in his secret plan. You can see why she calls to Hachiman to force him to this interesting event. But since she doesn’t know his true intention(s), I can assume that she doesn’t participate in Hayato’s plan 100%. She helps him a bit because she is just curious only. I will say that Haruno doesn’t know about Hayato’s multidimensional plan either. Because if she knows, I am sure she would not drag Hachiman to this event either.

Moreover, the solid evidence about Hayato plans to use Haruno to force Hachiman to participate in this his plan is…

How does she know Hachiman prefer to live in the house in the weekend?

Because Hayato again tells her that Hachiman would not go outside in the weekend. So he gives her this information (after Hachiman refused Hayato’s invitation, Hachiman is the one who told Hayato he will not leave from the house in the weekend.). See? Hayato records this valuable information and tells Haruno. This is how she can arrange the schedule so Hachiman can’t excuse he can’t go.

Hikigaya Hachiman refuses Yukinoshita Haruno's invitiation. (Oregairu Zoku ep4)
Seriously, why me?

Hayato knows Hachiman would refuse to join the group dates, so he reports Haruno about this. After she is curious why he needs Hachiman to some secret scheme, she ends up corporate with him. Now he can drag and use her to participate in his countermeasure. Moreover, when I say he drag Haruno to spy on this event, she doesn’t know he is destroying her operation secretly. And he wants her for other reasons as well. Right now, she doesn’t realize Hayato is using and drag her to his secret plan. Congratulations! You trick her successfully. Also Hachiman doesn’t realize Hayato will use him and end up burn him to ash.

Conclusion in Part 2

Hayato would plan his “multidimensional plan” in the same day he fell to Haruno’s trap to go out with those girls.

Hachiman is the starting point to Hayato’s plan.

Hayato can’t invite his own friends to join the group dates for many reasons.

Hachiman is the most necessary bait/victim for Hayato’s plan because he can solve big problems for him in one go. This time he can drag Haruno because he reports her that he invited and even bowed him but he refused. He use Hachiman as the trigger to drag her so he can use her force Hachiman and drag her to solve his big problems too.

Hayato mimics Haruno’s style to pretend he is stupid so he doesn’t know how Hachiman isn’t invited to the group.

The difference between “ask for help” and “pretending” of Hayato can be seen in the scene in anime Zoku ep2 when he asks Hachiman to help and ep4 when he asks Hachiman. His expressions in both scene are different.

Hayato knows Hachiman must refuse his invitation. But he prepared the next phase already. Hachiman’s rejection is the trigger for Hayato to use the trump card, Haruno, to force him to the group dates. Hayato reports to her how he invited and even bowed Hachiman but failed. This event makes she feels super duper curious and decides to help Hayato by forcing Hachiman to this event.

Moreover, Hayato can use the trigger to drag her to observe this event too. His plan right now is running smoothly even Haruno and Hachiman can’t notice.

This is how Hayato prepares by forcing Hachiman and dragging Haruno to his multidimensional plan. He uses Hachiman to drag Haruno, uses Haruno to force Hachiman. I hope you can catch up my analysis. In the part 3, I will explain how Hayato’s plan is running while he hangs out with Orimoto and Nakasomething, until they will reach that legendary cafe that he will activate “Holy Breath” there.

So if you have any question in this part 2 or previous part or have any thoughts, you can write your Comment. Your opinion is important!

And if you think my analysis is worth for other people to read too, Share buttons below will serve you.

If you want to receive the latest update of Yahari Bento!! blog, click Follow button and you can read the newest post before anyone. ;3

The List of The TRUTH(s) behind Hayato’s Sacrifice for Hachiman

Related Oregairu analysis you should not miss!

This boy is suffering people can’t save him.

The birth of Hayato’s multidimensional plan is because she wants to drive him into the endless despair.

The result of Haruno’s call to Hachiman is because Hayato makes her feel super curious.

If you finish reading the analysis above, this is next event.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Oregairu Analysis – The TRUTH(s) behind Hayato’s Sacrifice for Hachiman (Part 2)

  1. Honestly you are one of the best analyst of Oregairu I’ve ever seen. This was a great read for me, and your logic makes perfect sense.
    Hayama is much smarter than he shows huh? Before I always thought of him as just some pretty boy who would break under pressure when he sees what he doesn’t like. But I guess that’s not all he’s cracked up to be. As expected of Watari, no wonder he takes a long time to write. :D

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for following my work, @6ball.

      You are right. Hayama’s intelligence is on par with Haruno’s. I will make sure to reveal all potentials of Hayama to the very end. Because the analysis above only shows the top of iceberg (his true potential) only.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s